Sometimes I don’t understand why things as simple as a post can be difficult to write when there’s so much inspiration to write about. For me personally, I always feel like I fear disappointing my audience so I set standards that may feel too high to be accomplished. I’m told that this stress is from taking things too personally as I often write directly from the heart making me stubborn in style, but pure in tone. I think we all feel this way when we have an idea to say, just not the words to say it with. We rely on others to teach us how express what matters in our world, as without community; what are we?
I consider myself fortunate to be surrounded by people that have constantly supported me and have made life well… more awesome in their own ways. Whether it’s through a short ten minute chat or a ninety-minute class, I always know I can turn to them to turn my day around.
For holiday gifts this year, I knew I wanted to create them something that brought them as much joy as they’ve brought me. My inner, slightly jealous child of people that grew up with Christmas cookies was nagging me to create my own variety this winter. And so, I decided to bestow the gift of cookies. I knew shape sugar cookies were the usual for most, so I decided to add own my own twist by making all cookies have a chocolate base with some form of treat nestled in the dough. I also figured I should make three separate recipes/batches just to have back-up or in other words, I had a feeling a certain recipe would fail. The recipe did fail, but it was still edible enough to distribute among it’s counterpart peanut butter cookie…success!
To save some time, I decided to make two of the three batches of dough beforehand then just have one massive baking session. I highly suggest doing so as I ended up spending close to five hours both baking, making the final batch of dough, and packaging all the cookies like so:

For my friends, I chose a caramel centered cookie that I knew would be easy to make and even easier for them to recreate. If wasn’t for their support, I probably would’ve stopped baking a while ago; thus making the recreation ease even more important to me. All you really have to do is whip up a very stand mixer friendly dough, cover caramels with the chocolaty goodness, bake on a silicone mat, then wait a few minutes for the caramel to stick to the inside of the cookie and not stick to the mat.
A handy tip I learned was to allow the fresh baked cookies to cool on the rack flipped over so any dripped out caramel could cool completely without attacking wire cooling racks. These suckers don’t really spread out while baking, so I managed to bake about twelve per sheet at a time.
A few hours after handing the gifts out, I received a text about these cookies that made every second of those five hours baking worth. I swear, these were the exact words: “WHAT WAS IN THAT COOKIE THAT MADE IT TASTE LIKE HEAVEN?”
Chewy Caramel Chocolate Cookies
From My Cooking Adventures; yield is about forty.
1 cup butter
1 cup sugar
1cup brown sugar
2 eggs
1 tablespoon vanilla extract
3/4 cup cocoa powder
1 teaspoon baking soda
1/4 teaspoon salt
2 1/2 cups flour
Caramels (I just used the Kraft brand ones)
Preheat oven to 350 degrees
Cream together butter and both types of sugar in a stand mixer. Once it is light and fluffy add in the eggs one at a time. Then mix in the vanilla extract. Add in cocoa powder, baking soda and salt, mix until well combined. Mix in the flour and mix until smooth-ish. Some lumps are ok, they will bake out.
Take a tablespoon or so of dough and wrap it around the caramel. Place it on a cookie sheet (I lined mine with silicone mats – it helped when some of the caramel oozed out!) Bake for 11-13 minutes. Let cool and enjoy

The second of the three cookies was supposed to turn out into a cloud-like marshmellow filled cookie of joy simply called Jessica’s Marshmellow Clouds from a Mrs. Field’s cookbook. Don’t get me wrong, they were 100% edible and even tasty, just not high enough to my baking standards to give out the recipe.

Before baking

After baking; you can tell I burned the marshmellows so the cookie would be fully cooked.
And last but not but least; the final batch of cookies(peanut butter) AKA the Saving Grace to my teachers’ gifts. These were the first leg of my five hours baking, so I was extremely vivacious and hopeful while baking them.
If you also really want to bake these peanut butter cookies but lacking enough peanut butter like I did, you can create your own peanut butter dough substitute. Simply melt about a cup or so of chips in the microwave then stir in about two tablespoons of butter and about a third of a cup of powdered sugar. Problem solved.

Like the Caramel Cookies from above, all you really have to do to bake these is to cover something already tasty with something even more tasty then wait. The peanut butter dough I had made easily molded into chips similar to those chocolate melting chips you can buy at craft stores for things such as cake pops. I found it easier to layer the peanut butter between two dough patties instead of inserting it into a ball of cookie dough.

And if you watch the occasional South Park episode like me, it’s perfectly acceptable to sing the Salty Balls about…now.
By far, out of all the cookies I gave out, these were my favorite. The crisp outside gives away to a decadent center of peanut butter encased by melt in your mouth chocolate—what’s not to love?! If you think they’re fantastic alone, try them while drinking tea…I promise you, it’s a fantastic way to start the day.
Magic In The Middle Cookies
Adapted from The Patterned Plate
Chocolate dough: 1.5 cups flour
1/2 cup unsweetened cocoa powder
1/2 tsp baking soda
1/4 tsp salt
1/2 cup granulated sugar
1/2 cup brown sugar
1/2 cup(1 stick) butter
1/4 cup peanut butter(use what you have on hand; I used crunchy)
1 tsp vanilla extract
1 large egg+ 1 large egg yolk
Peanut butter dough:
~1 cup Reese’s peanut butter chips
powdered sugar(to taste)
2 tbs butter
Preheat oven to 350 and line two baking sheets with parchment paper.
For chocolate dough: beat sugars, butter, and peanut butter until light and fluffy. Beat in vanilla and egg. Stir in dry ingredients until well blended. Dough should be soft and thick. Set aside.
For peanut butter dough: melt chips in microwave and stir in remaining ingredients until butter is melted and paste like consistency is achieved.
Sandwich a teaspoon of peanut butter dough between two tablespoons of chocolate dough. Roll into granulated sugar. Repeat until all dough is used.
Flatten balls using either your hands or a glass to a 2.5 cm thickness. Bake for 7-9 minutes. Allow five minutes for cooling and hardening before transferring to a cooling rack.

As I sat down later that night, my legs were sore and I was exhausted but excited. And let these two cookie recipes prove to anyone that homemade gifts may be the most work, but they truly are the best.
May whatever holiday you celebrate be as sweet as the sugar you bake with.
Happy holidays!